Budget vs premium
Start Willow vs Novi: Which Costs Less Over 12 Months? (2026)
Compare Start Willow and Novi on real cost over 12 months, medication type, price stability and support. Independent 2026 analysis, no first-month gimmicks.
Published · Pricing as published in our provider dataset, synced · Editorial scores 7.3 and 7.0 out of 10
We may receive compensation when you click partner links. Rankings are based on research methodology, not sponsorship.
Both Start Willow and Novi will get a GLP-1 prescription to your door without an in-person visit. The question is what the year after that first shipment looks like.
Start Willow costs 2.2x more per month than Novi once promotional pricing is out of the picture ($299/mo against $133/mo). Over a year that gap compounds into real money, and the question is what it buys.
This comparison works from what each provider publishes: the entry price, what it becomes at month two, the medication actually dispensed, and what is bundled rather than billed. Anything a provider declines to disclose is marked undisclosed rather than filled in.
The short answer
- Lowest 12-month cost
- Novi — $1,596 against $3,538 at Start Willow, on each provider's own best published pricing.
- Most support for the money
- Novi — No long-term contract, cancel anytime.
- Fastest route to a first shipment
- Novi — Online intake, then free 2-day shipping with every order.
- Most support included
- Novi — No long-term contract, cancel anytime.
The short version: Start Willow vs Novi
Nothing in this table is our estimate. Where a provider does not publish something, the cell says so.
| Start Willow | Novi | |
|---|---|---|
| Advertised price | From $249 the first month, then $299/mo | Semaglutide from $133/mo, tirzepatide from $166/mo |
| Rate after promotions | $299/mo | $133/mo |
| Pricing structure | Promotional first month, then standard rate | Published rate per medication |
| Medication | Compounded semaglutide and compounded tirzepatide | Compounded semaglutide and compounded tirzepatide |
| Shipping | Delivery guaranteed in 3 days or less | Free 2-day shipping with every order |
| Support model | No coaching program stated | No coaching program stated |
| Tirzepatide | Available | $166/mo |
| Price transparency | Published upfront | Published upfront |
| Patient reviews | 6,385 | 50,124 |
| eRxDoctor score | 7.3/10 | 7.0/10 |
Cost over a full course of treatment
The advertised rate answers the wrong question. The totals below are the honest version, built from the rates each provider publishes.
| Start Willow | Novi | |
|---|---|---|
| First month | $249 | $133 |
| Months 2 onward | $299/mo | $133/mo |
| 6-month total | $1,744 | $798 |
| 12-month total | $3,538 | $1,596 |
| Best published plan | No multi-month discount published | No multi-month discount published |
The twelve-month spread is $1,942. That is the number to hold Start Willow against: it has to justify roughly $162 extra every month.
Price escalation to plan for: Start Willow moves from $249 to $299, a 20% increase. Set a calendar reminder for the month it changes.
What the price difference actually buys
Before treating the cheaper option as the obvious one, it is worth naming what the more expensive one includes — at Start Willow that is direct-pay model that bypasses insurance pre-authorization, plus delivery guaranteed in 3 days or less.
Novi's answer is the narrowest gap here between semaglutide and tirzepatide pricing, at $133 and $166. What it does not carry: the $133 rate depends on a $200-off promotion and there is no outcome guarantee.
The premium buys attention. If you expect to need it — first GLP-1, side effects you will want triaged quickly, a history of stalling around week ten — it is money well spent. If you do not, it is not.
How Start Willow works
From $249 per Month Against Novi, that puts it in the position of the more expensive option.
The process is fully online, no in-person visits, then delivery guaranteed in 3 days or less. On money, expect promotional first month, then standard rate — published upfront.
Behind the prescription sits direct-pay model that bypasses insurance pre-authorization. Available medication: compounded semaglutide and compounded tirzepatide.
Start Willow pros
- Medications comparable to Ozempic and tirzepatide
- No insurance needed and no membership fees
- Direct-pay model bypasses insurance pre-authorization entirely
- Delivery guaranteed in 3 days or less
Start Willow cons
- Price rises from $249 first month to $299/month ongoing
- Ongoing $299/month is among the higher rates on this list
- Compounded medication only, no branded Ozempic or Wegovy
Read next to Novi, the weak point: at $299 ongoing it is among the most expensive compounded programs here.
Inside the Novi program
$200 OFF - GLP-1 for $133 Today What it is really selling here is the narrowest gap here between semaglutide and tirzepatide pricing, at $133 and $166.
Getting started means online intake, after which free 2-day shipping with every order. Pricing runs on a published rate per medication basis, published upfront.
On the clinical side, no long-term contract, cancel anytime, prescribing compounded semaglutide and compounded tirzepatide.
Novi pros
- Largest patient base on this list, 50,000+ patients, signaling operational maturity
- Competitive pricing: semaglutide from $133/month and tirzepatide from $166/month
- Free 2-day shipping included with every order
- Both compounded semaglutide and tirzepatide available
Novi cons
- Tirzepatide ($166) costs more than the semaglutide entry rate
- Compounded medication only, no branded Ozempic, Wegovy, or Zepbound
- No published outcome or weight loss guarantee
The reservation worth holding, particularly next to Start Willow: the $133 rate depends on a $200-off promotion and there is no outcome guarantee.
Picking between them
Choose Start Willow if:
- you would get real value from a delivery guarantee of three days or less and no membership stacked on the medication price
- the level of clinical contact suits you: direct-pay model that bypasses insurance pre-authorization
- you want to start on their timeline: fully online, no in-person visits
- delivery works the way you want it to: delivery guaranteed in 3 days or less
Choose Novi if:
- you would rather use the platform with the longer public record (50,124 reviews)
- the monthly rate is the constraint — $133/mo against $299/mo
- the feature you would actually use: the narrowest gap here between semaglutide and tirzepatide pricing, at $133 and $166
- the twelve-month total is what you are optimizing ($1,596 against $3,538)
Honest trade-offs
On price. The monthly gap is 2.2x in Novi's favor. Whether that is a saving or a false economy turns on one thing: the $133 rate depends on a $200-off promotion and there is no outcome guarantee.
On predictability. The pricing structures differ (promotional first month, then standard rate versus published rate per medication), and structure, not headline rate, determines the twelve-month bill.
On access. Start Willow advertises fully online, no in-person visits and delivery guaranteed in 3 days or less; Novi advertises online intake and free 2-day shipping with every order. Neither publishes its state coverage, so confirm you are eligible before paying for anything.
On medication. Start Willow covers compounded semaglutide and compounded tirzepatide; Novi covers compounded semaglutide and compounded tirzepatide. Neither locks you out of a molecule the other offers, so this is unlikely to be the deciding factor.
What the evidence actually says
Both platforms sell access to the same drug class, so the clinical record below applies equally to each.
Compounded drugs are not FDA-approved, and the agency does not verify their safety, effectiveness or quality before they reach a patient, per FDA.
The rules governing which pharmacies may compound, and under what conditions, sit in sections 503A and 503B of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, per FDA.
Which is to say: the medication decision belongs with a clinician, and the platform decision belongs with a spreadsheet.
Start Willow vs Novi: common questions
Which is cheaper to start, Start Willow or Novi?
Novi, at $133 against $249. Note that the cheapest first month and the cheapest year are often different providers here — check the 12-month row of the cost table before deciding on the entry price.
Which costs less over a year, Start Willow or Novi?
Novi, at roughly $1,596 for twelve months against $3,538 at Start Willow, using each provider's own best published pricing. Those totals cover medication and program fees as published; they exclude anything a provider bills separately, and they assume you stay on the same plan for the full year.
What happens if I stop taking the medication?
Neither Start Willow nor Novi penalizes you for stopping, but the medication does. The published follow-up data on withdrawal shows substantial regain, which is why the twelve-month totals above matter more than either provider's introductory offer.
Is Start Willow or Novi better for a first GLP-1 prescription?
For a first prescription, weight support over price. Start Willow offers more contact (direct-pay model that bypasses insurance pre-authorization), which matters most in the first eight weeks when side effects and titration questions are at their peak. Once you know how you tolerate the medication, the cheaper program becomes the rational choice.
Are Start Willow and Novi legitimate?
Both are licensed telehealth platforms that route a prescription through a clinician review before anything is dispensed; neither sells medication without one. Start Willow operates on promotional first month, then standard rate with pricing published upfront, Novi on published rate per medication, published upfront. The meaningful due diligence is on the medication category and the terms, not on whether the platforms are real.
The verdict
Novi is the cheaper year by $1,942, and for a straightforward course of treatment that settles it.
The case for Start Willow is a delivery guarantee of three days or less and no membership stacked on the medication price. That is worth $162 a month to some patients and nothing at all to others — be honest about which you are.
Get the maintenance-dose price in writing from whichever one you pick. That single question prevents most of the regret in this category.
Keep comparing
- Shed vs Start WillowPublished price vs quote-only
- Hers vs Start WillowBrand-name vs compounded
- Directmeds vs NoviPublished price vs quote-only
- Enhance MD vs NoviBudget vs premium
- Refills vs Start WillowBudget vs premium
- Enhance MD vs LIV BodyBudget vs premium
See every provider in context on the weight loss rankings, or browse the full comparison index.
Disclaimers and methodology
Medical content is informational only and does not replace professional diagnosis, treatment, or emergency care.
Some links are affiliate links and may generate commission at no extra cost to you.
Pricing reflects what each provider published as of the sync date above and changes frequently; confirm the current rate, and the rate at your maintenance dose, before you pay. Six- and twelve-month totals are calculated from those published rates and exclude anything a provider bills separately.
eRxDoctor is an independent publisher. It is not a medical provider, is not affiliated with or endorsed by Start Willow or Novi, and does not sell treatment. Read our ranking methodology.